TMT went to its first invitational, attending the Crimson Classic, as well as sending two teams to the Jamaica, Queens Regional in New York City. During the off-season, TMT went through a significant re-organization, creating the forerunner of its present Constitution, as well as solidifying its financial position with the Tufts Community Union.

TMT attended various invitationals, and sent two teams to the New Haven Regional, and one team to the Bristol Regional. The program ran a Quidnunc Course through the Tufts Experimental College, allowing members to advance their skills and receive academic credit for the significant work done throughout the year. This year, TMT achieved its first national bid out of New Haven to the Hamilton, Ohio National Tournament, placing third overall in that Regional. In Ohio, the Tufts team ranked well against the high-caliber competition there.

TMT elected two new Co-Presidents, Jim Wright '09 and Rebekah Sokol '10, while outgoing Co-President Jeffrey Kiok '09 graduated early and became an alumni coach. The program expanded to four teams after competitive tryouts. TMT Co-President Rebekah Sokol and Jeffrey Kiok co-taught an Explorations Course (an advising option for incoming Tufts first-year students) in the fall semester, while Rebekah and Jim taught the annual Mock Trial Quidnunc course in the spring semester. Additionally, in November, the program hosted the First Annual Mumbo Jumbo Invitational Tournament, which was quite successful. As well as expanding within the Tufts community, TMT had a very successful season. TMT won two bids out of the Boston Regional to the Memphis, Tennessee Opening Round Championship Site (ORCS). Furthermore, two additional Tufts teams competed in the Bristol, Rhode Island Regional, winning another bid there to an ORCS in Greenville, South Carolina. TMT ultimately declined its third bid, and sent two teams to Memphis. At the 2009 Memphis ORCS, team 1402 garnered 5 wins, receiving an honorable mention and coming up 1 win short of qualifying for the National Championship, while team 1401 won 3 ballots.

In 2009-2010, under the direction of Co-Presidents Rebekah Sokol '10 and Jon Lautin '11 continued to improve. The second annual Mumbo Jumbo Invitation proved to be a huge success with more teams, better competition, and better judging. In the Spring, TMT won one bid at the Providence, RI AMTA Regional Tournament as well as four individual awards. Team 1602 then went on to compete at the Boston ORCS, where Tufts finished with a 7-1 record, qualifying us for the NCT for the first time in our short history.

Under the leadership of Tomas Garcia and Jon Lautin, TMT continued to grow in 2010-11. Tufts won its first two invitational tournaments in the fall, finishing 8-0 at both UNH's Wildcat Invitational and our own Mumbo Jumbo Invitational. At regionals, Tufts qualified two Teams to ORCS, finishing 6-1-1 and 6-2 at the Worchester Regional. For the second year in a row we attended the NCT, after placing 4th at a very difficult White Plains ORCS. At the NCT, Team 1602 finished 6-2, good enough for 3rd in the Conlin Division, and 5th in the nation!